Skip to content
yymaxx.ing / reef
Back to the reef

Trying to build a reef I won’t hate maintaining

Water changes killed my motivation with freshwater tanks. This time I started from the chore list and worked backwards.

A small reef aquarium photographed by Martin Guerre

Photo: Martin Guerre · CC0

Confession: in my freshwater days, the part I hated most wasn't the fish. It was water changes. Specifically, sucking on the end of a hose to get the siphon going.

So with this tank, I started from the chore list and worked backwards. Can I skip the filter? Can I skip water changes? (Spoiler: one of those is a yes.)

No filter

I've covered the why in the rock post: the rock holds the bacteria, and the macroalgae soaks up the nitrate. So no HOB, no canister, no skimmer, no sump. That's a lot less gear to clean.

The trade-off is that nothing catches the gunk. Leftover food, fish poop and bits of dead algae just settle wherever the water drops them. So where does it go?

Most of it gets eaten by the same bacteria on the rock and sand. They break it down into ammonia, then nitrate, and the macroalgae soaks that up. That only works if there isn't more gunk than they can keep up with, which is why I'll go easy on feeding and keep the stocking light.

Flow does the next bit of work. If the water keeps moving, gunk stays out in the open instead of piling up in dead corners behind the rock.

Later on, a cleanup crew helps too. Small snails eat algae and leftovers, and tiny critters like copepods pick through the sand. Snails only go in once there's actually something for them to eat, so not during cycling.

Whatever's left, I suck out during water changes. That's one reason the rocks are going in as islands with open sand between them: I can actually reach the spots where stuff collects.

No filter doesn't mean no water movement though. Corals need flow, and the water surface needs to keep moving so the tank gets enough oxygen. I've ordered a small DC circulation pump to start, but for 90 cm I'll probably need a proper wavemaker eventually.

If I end up needing a HOB filter later because it saves me work, I'll add one. No ego here.

Making water changes less gross before making them less frequent

The first fix is simple: no more mouth siphoning. Water changes will be done with a pump.

I got two collapsible 10 L buckets (S$17.99) for water changes, so they fold flat when I'm not using them. The routine is old water out, freshly mixed saltwater in.

PSA: turn the ATO off before a water change. Otherwise, the moment the water level drops, it starts pumping freshwater in to "fix" it, and you end up diluting your tank (more on the ATO here).

The real experiment: monthly water changes?

Here's what I actually want to find out. With light stocking and macroalgae doing a lot of the cleanup, can the tank go about a month between water changes?

I'm not starting there. The plan is something like 7 L a week to begin with, then stretch the gap slowly once the tank is stable and the test results stay good. If something looks off, it gets a water change, experiment or not.

I also want to count the work honestly. If I skip water changes but spend that time trimming algae and testing water instead, that's not really less work. So I'll track the time, not just the litres.

xo, yy


Some links in this article are affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you buy through them.